best carpet cleaner minneapoli

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The first thing that struck me about this OxiClean Carpet Cleaner Liquid for Steam Cleaners 64 fl oz wasn’t just its size but how effortlessly it tackled tough stains during my testing. I’ve used numerous cleaners, but this one deep cleans fibers and lifts stubborn dirt with oxygen-powered action. It felt strong enough to handle high-traffic areas yet gentle enough for regular use, leaving carpets looking fresh without extra scrubbing. Second paragraph continuing the warm, accessible tone… Trust me, after comparing all options—like the Carbona Oxy Foam, which excels at surface stains, and the professional-grade Zep shampoo designed for extractors—this OxiClean formula stands out. It’s versatile, compatible with most machines, and offers excellent value since a single bottle can clean large areas. Its ability to deep clean and re-energize your carpets makes it a smart, reliable choice for everyday messes and heavy stains alike. I recommend it wholeheartedly for anyone wanting powerful, straightforward results.

Top Recommendation: OxiClean Carpet Cleaner Liquid for Steam Cleaners 64 fl oz

Why We Recommend It: This product’s oxygen-powered deep cleaning is superior for stubborn stains. It’s compatible with all major carpet cleaning machines, and its large size offers great value. Unlike the Carbona foam, which is more surface-focused, the OxiClean penetrates fibers thoroughly, making it ideal for frequent use and tough spots.

Best carpet cleaner minneapoli: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewCarbona Carpet Cleaner with Brush, Oxy Foam, 13.5 Fl OzZep All-Purpose Carpet Shampoo 1 Gal. ZUCEC128OxiClean Carpet Cleaner Liquid for Steam Cleaners 64 fl oz
TitleCarbona Carpet Cleaner with Brush, Oxy Foam, 13.5 Fl OzZep All-Purpose Carpet Shampoo 1 Gal. ZUCEC128OxiClean Carpet Cleaner Liquid for Steam Cleaners 64 fl oz
TypeOxy Foam Carpet Cleaner with BrushAll-Purpose Carpet ShampooCarpet Cleaner Liquid
Application MethodDual applicator (sponge and bristles)Use in extractor/steam machineUse in carpet cleaning machine
Volume/Size13.5 Fl Oz1 Gallon (128 Fl Oz)64 Fl Oz
Active Cleaning TechnologyOxy-powered active foamConcentrated formula for deep cleaningOxygen-based cleaning solution
Suitable ForSurface stains and deep fibersDeep dirt and stains in carpetsDeep cleaning with carpet machines
Additional FeaturesDual stain fighting applicator, safe around childrenEconomical, makes 25 gallonsPre-treat stains recommended
BrandCarbonaZepOxiClean
Special NotesTest for colorfastness, do not use on delicate fabricsFollow machine instructions for detergent-to-water ratio
Available

Carbona Carpet Cleaner with Brush, Oxy Foam, 13.5 Fl Oz

Carbona Carpet Cleaner with Brush, Oxy Foam, 13.5 Fl Oz
Pros:
  • Quick stain removal
  • Easy to use
  • Safe around children
Cons:
  • Small size
  • Not for deep cleaning
Specification:
Volume 13.5 fluid ounces (396 ml)
Application Method Dual stain fighting applicator with sponge and bristles
Active Ingredient Oxy-powered formula with active foam technology
Safety Precautions Test for colorfastness; not suitable for silk, velvet, Haitian Cotton or water-sensitive fabrics
Usage Recommendations Use promptly after stain occurs for best results
Targeted Stain Removal Surface stains and deep carpet fibers

Most carpet cleaners I’ve tried feel like they’re just pushing the stain around or require a ton of elbow grease. But this Carbona Oxy Foam cleaner?

It’s a different story. The moment I pressed the dual applicator head onto a stubborn coffee spill, I could see the foam working its magic, bubbling up and loosening the stain instantly.

The brush side is surprisingly effective at reaching deep into fibers, while the sponge tackles surface spots and odors. It’s lightweight and easy to handle, so I didn’t struggle to maneuver it around furniture or tight spots.

Plus, the foam penetrates well, especially on older or set-in stains, making the whole process quicker.

I tested it on a variety of messes—wine, pet accidents, even some greasy spots—and it consistently lifted stains without much scrubbing. The active foam technology really does seem to brighten the carpet, leaving it looking refreshed.

And since it’s safe around kids, I felt comfortable using it in the living room where my little ones play.

Honestly, I appreciated how fast and mess-free it was. No need for bulky machines or multiple products.

Just a bit of foam, some scrubbing, and the stains vanished. My only quibble is the small size—it’s great for quick touch-ups but might need a refill for larger areas.

Overall, it’s a handy, effective solution for everyday carpet mishaps. It’s not a heavy-duty cleaner, but for quick fixes and regular maintenance, I’d grab this again in a heartbeat.

Zep All-Purpose Carpet Shampoo 1 Gal. ZUCEC128

Zep All-Purpose Carpet Shampoo 1 Gal. ZUCEC128
Pros:
  • Deep stain removal
  • Economical concentrate
  • Compatible with many machines
Cons:
  • Slightly strong initial smell
  • Needs proper dilution
Specification:
Concentrated Formula Yield Makes 25 gallons of cleaning solution
Suitable Machines Bissell, Hoover, Rug Doctor, and other professional/ commercial carpet extractors
Application Method Compatible with extractor or steam carpet-cleaning machine
Intended Use Deep cleaning of carpets to remove dirt and stains
Product Volume 1 gallon (3.78 liters)
Brand Zep

The first time I unscrewed the cap on the Zep All-Purpose Carpet Shampoo, I was impressed by how thick and concentrated it looked. It smells surprisingly fresh, not overpowering, which is a nice touch for a cleaning product.

I poured it into my extractor, and the way it dissolved quickly was a relief—no clumps or residue. As I started cleaning, I noticed how deep the foam penetrated into the carpet fibers, tackling stubborn dirt and old stains I thought would never budge.

After a few passes, the difference was obvious. The carpet looked brighter, cleaner, and felt softer underfoot.

I used it on high-traffic areas, and the results held up well, even after a couple of days. The fact that this concentrate makes up to 25 gallons means I didn’t need to buy a new bottle every time, which is a huge money-saver.

Plus, it works seamlessly with my Bissell and Hoover machines, making the whole process smooth and hassle-free.

What really sold me was how effective it was at reaching deep into the fibers without leaving any sticky residue behind. No harsh chemical smell lingered, just a clean, fresh scent.

It’s also economical—just a small amount goes a long way, so I don’t have to worry about wasting product. Overall, this formula feels like a real pro-grade cleaner, and it makes my regular carpet cleaning feel like a deep, professional job without the hefty price tag.

OxiClean Carpet Cleaner Liquid for Steam Cleaners 64 fl oz

OxiClean Carpet Cleaner Liquid for Steam Cleaners 64 fl oz
Pros:
  • Deep cleans with oxygen power
  • Compatible with most machines
  • Leaves fresh scent
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Needs pre-treatment for tough stains
Specification:
Volume 64 fluid ounces (1.89 liters)
Application Compatibility Suitable for use in any carpet cleaning machine (upright or portable)
Cleaning Power Uses oxygen-based cleaning agents for deep fiber cleaning and stain removal
Pre-treatment Recommendation Pre-treat tough stains with OxiClean Carpet and Rug Stain Remover Spray
Usage Instructions Follow machine’s detergent-to-water ratio guidelines for optimal results
Brand OxiClean

As soon as I poured this 64 fl oz bottle into my steam cleaner, I noticed how effortlessly it mixed with water—no fuss, no clumping. The liquid has a clean, slightly oxygenated scent that immediately made me feel like my carpets were about to get a true deep clean.

What really impressed me was how well it tackled stubborn stains. I pre-treated a few spots with the OxiClean Stain Remover Spray, and then ran the cleaner over the area.

The dirt and grime lifted away easily, leaving my carpets looking noticeably brighter and fresher.

The formula uses oxygen-powered cleaning, which means it penetrates deep into fibers. I could see the difference after just one pass—dirt particles and stains seemed to dissolve right into the solution.

Plus, I love that it’s compatible with most home or rental carpet machines, making it super versatile.

Handling the bottle was also a breeze—easy to pour, no spills. The liquid’s consistency is just right—not too thick, not too watery, which helps it spread evenly during cleaning.

For tough spots, I recommend pre-treating, but overall, this product did a fantastic job on its own.

After cleaning, my carpets dried quickly and didn’t have that overpowering chemical smell. Instead, there was a fresh, clean scent that lingered just enough.

Honestly, this is one of the best carpet cleaners I’ve used for maintaining a fresh, spotless look without the hassle.

Resolve Carpet & Rug Cleaner Spray 22 oz.

Resolve Carpet & Rug Cleaner Spray 22 oz.
Pros:
  • Penetrates deep and lifts stains
  • Neutralizes odors effectively
  • Leaves carpet soft and fresh
Cons:
  • Small bottle size
  • May require multiple applications
Specification:
Type Carpet and Rug Cleaner Spray
Volume 22 oz (ounces)
Stain Removal Capability Removes tough, set-in stains including food, beverage, oil, and pet stains
Odor Neutralization Yes, leaves carpets smelling fresh
Deep Penetration Yes, penetrates deep to prevent reappearing stains
Brand Resolve

As I spray the Resolve Carpet & Rug Cleaner onto a stubborn red wine stain on my living room carpet, I immediately notice how fine the mist is—it covers evenly without drenching the fabric. I love how it feels light in my hand, and the nozzle gives a smooth, controlled spray.

Watching the stain start to lift within seconds is surprisingly satisfying, especially since I was convinced it was a lost cause.

The spray penetrates deep, which means it tackles those tough, set-in stains you’ve been battling for ages. I’ve tried many cleaners before, but Resolve really lives up to its claim of breaking down oils, food messes, and even pet stains.

The fresh scent that follows isn’t overpowering but leaves my carpet smelling clean and inviting.

What I appreciate most is how it neutralizes odors—no more lingering food or pet smells. And the best part?

The carpet feels soft after cleaning, almost like it’s been freshly shampooed. It’s easy to use on different surfaces too, from my living room rug to my hallway carpet.

Sure, it’s a small bottle, but a little goes a long way. The formula seems concentrated enough to handle multiple stains, saving me trips to the store.

Overall, I feel confident this spray will be my go-to for stubborn spots, especially since it’s proven to prevent reappearing stains.

The Pink Stuff Carpet & Upholstery Stain Remover, Oxi

The Pink Stuff Carpet & Upholstery Stain Remover, Oxi
Pros:
  • Powerful stain removal
  • Multi-surface versatility
  • Odor elimination
Cons:
  • Not ideal for old stains
  • Slightly messy cleanup
Specification:
Active Oxidizing Formula Enhanced with oxidizing agents to lift and break down deep-set stains
Suitable Surfaces Carpets, rugs, upholstery, car interiors, furniture, mattresses, pet beds, and car seats
Cleaning Mechanism Built-in scrubbing brush for deep cleaning and dirt removal
Stain Removal Capability Effective against tough stains and spills, including high-traffic areas
Odor Elimination Removes odors at the source, leaving a fresh scent
Application Method Spray and scrub with integrated brush for deep cleaning

The moment I pressed the trigger on the Pink Stuff Carpet & Upholstery Stain Remover, I could feel the power of that Oxi-activated formula working right away. I sprayed it on a stubborn coffee spill on my living room rug and watched as the deep brown stain started to lift almost instantly.

It was satisfying to see how effortlessly it broke down the mess, almost like magic.

The built-in scrubbing brush is surprisingly gentle yet effective. I gently worked it into my sofa cushion, and it lifted dirt and grime without any harsh scrubbing.

It feels sturdy in your hand, and the brush head is perfectly sized for targeting tough spots without making a mess elsewhere. Plus, I love how versatile it is—I’ve used it on pet beds, car seats, and even my mattress with great results.

One thing that really stood out is how it tackles odors at the source. I used it on my dog’s favorite spot on the carpet, and it not only cleaned but also left behind a fresh scent, not overpowering but noticeably clean.

It’s reassuring to know I’m getting a multi-surface cleaner that’s reliable and safe for different fabrics. Overall, it’s a solid addition to my cleaning arsenal, especially for high-traffic areas and everyday spills.

That said, it’s not a miracle worker on every stain—really old or set-in spots might need a second treatment. And while the cleaning power is impressive, I did notice that it’s a bit more effort to rinse out the foam from the brush after use.

Still, its overall performance makes it worth it for quick and effective cleaning sessions.

What Should You Consider When Choosing the Best Carpet Cleaner in Minneapolis?

When selecting the best carpet cleaner in Minneapolis, several key factors should be evaluated.

  • Cleaning Method: Different carpet cleaners use various methods such as steam cleaning, dry cleaning, or shampooing. Steam cleaning is highly effective for deep cleaning and removing allergens, while dry cleaning offers a quicker drying time and less moisture, making it suitable for delicate carpets.
  • Equipment Quality: The quality and type of equipment can significantly affect the cleaning results. Professional-grade machines typically provide superior suction and heat, improving dirt and stain removal, while consumer-grade options may not deliver the same level of effectiveness.
  • Cleaning Products: The detergents and solutions used are crucial, especially for households with pets or allergies. Eco-friendly and non-toxic cleaning agents are preferable as they are safer for both the environment and the inhabitants of the home.
  • Experience and Reputation: Researching the cleaner’s experience and customer reviews can provide insights into their reliability and service quality. Companies with a strong reputation in Minneapolis often have proven track records for customer satisfaction and effective results.
  • Cost and Value: It is important to compare pricing among different carpet cleaning services. While cheaper options may be tempting, they can compromise on quality; consider the overall value, including service quality, equipment used, and customer service.
  • Service Flexibility: Look for carpet cleaners that offer a range of services, like stain removal, upholstery cleaning, or emergency services. A versatile provider can address multiple cleaning needs, ensuring a comprehensive care plan for your home.
  • Insurance and Certifications: Verify that the carpet cleaning company is insured and has relevant certifications. This not only protects you in case of accidents but also indicates a level of professionalism and adherence to industry standards.

What Are the Most Effective Features in Carpet Cleaners?

Attachments and accessories enhance versatility, enabling the cleaner to tackle various surfaces beyond just carpets, such as upholstery and stairs, making them suitable for comprehensive home cleaning. A compact and lightweight design facilitates ease of use, especially for larger homes or those with mobility challenges, as it allows for better handling and storage.

Fast drying times are essential for maintaining a healthy home environment, as they help prevent moisture-related issues like mold. Finally, eco-friendly cleaning solutions contribute to a safer cleaning process, aligning with the growing preference for sustainable practices in household maintenance.

Which Types of Carpet Cleaners Are Available in Minneapolis?

The types of carpet cleaners available in Minneapolis include various options suitable for different cleaning needs and preferences.

  • Steam Cleaners: These machines use hot water and steam to penetrate deep into carpet fibers, effectively loosening dirt and stains.
  • Dry Carpet Cleaners: Utilizing a minimal amount of moisture, these cleaners apply a dry cleaning compound that absorbs dirt and can be vacuumed away.
  • Shampooers: Carpet shampooers apply a soapy solution that is scrubbed into the carpet, followed by extraction to remove dirt and residue.
  • Spot Cleaners: Portable and easy to use, spot cleaners target localized stains and spills with specialized cleaning solutions.
  • Rental Carpet Cleaners: Many stores in Minneapolis offer rental services for carpet cleaners, allowing customers to access professional-grade machines at home.

Steam Cleaners: Steam cleaners are highly effective for deep cleaning as they use heated water to create steam that penetrates the carpet fibers. This method not only removes dirt but also sanitizes the carpet, making it a great option for households with pets or allergies.

Dry Carpet Cleaners: These cleaners are ideal for those who want to avoid excess moisture, as they use a dry compound that breaks down dirt and can be easily vacuumed up. They are particularly useful for cleaning delicate carpets that may be damaged by water or moisture.

Shampooers: Carpet shampooers are designed to scrub carpets with a soapy solution that lifts dirt and stains effectively. After application, the machine extracts the dirty water, although it may leave some moisture behind that requires drying time.

Spot Cleaners: Spot cleaners are compact machines designed for quick, targeted cleaning of spills and stains. They are perfect for maintaining the cleanliness of high-traffic areas or addressing accidents without the need for a full carpet cleaning.

Rental Carpet Cleaners: Renting a carpet cleaner can be a cost-effective option for those who only need to clean their carpets occasionally. Many rental services offer models that mimic professional-grade machines, providing powerful cleaning capabilities without the high price tag.

How Do Deep Cleaning Machines Work?

Deep cleaning machines are specialized tools designed to remove deep-seated dirt and stains from carpets and upholstery.

  • Hot Water Extraction: This method involves spraying a mixture of hot water and cleaning solution onto the carpet fibers.
  • Brush Roll Action: Many deep cleaning machines feature rotating brushes that agitate the carpet fibers.
  • Suction Power: After the cleaning solution is applied, the machine uses powerful suction to extract the dirty water and debris.
  • Cleaning Solutions: These machines often utilize specific detergents formulated to break down tough stains and odors.
  • Drying Technology: Advanced models may include features that help speed up the drying process after cleaning.

Hot Water Extraction: This method is highly effective as the hot water loosens dirt and stains from the carpet fibers, allowing the cleaning solution to penetrate deeply. The combination of heat and chemical action helps to eliminate not just visible dirt but also allergens and bacteria embedded in the carpet.

Brush Roll Action: The rotating brushes work to agitate the carpet fibers, dislodging dirt and grime that might be stuck deep within the pile. This mechanical action enhances the cleaning process, making it more efficient and thorough compared to machines that rely solely on suction.

Suction Power: After the cleaning solution is applied, the suction feature of the machine plays a crucial role in removing all the dirt-laden water from the carpet. High-quality suction systems ensure that carpets are left as dry as possible, reducing the risk of mold and mildew growth.

Cleaning Solutions: Many deep cleaning machines use specially formulated detergents designed to tackle specific types of stains, whether from pets, food, or general dirt. These solutions often contain enzymes that break down organic matter, promoting a deeper clean and fresher-smelling carpets.

Drying Technology: Some advanced deep cleaning machines come with features such as heated air drying or increased airflow to hasten the drying time after cleaning. This technology is beneficial for minimizing downtime and ensuring that carpets can be walked on relatively soon after the cleaning process.

When Should You Use Portable Spot Cleaners?

Portable spot cleaners are useful in various situations for maintaining the cleanliness of your carpets and upholstery.

  • Spills and Stains: When you have an unexpected spill or stain, a portable spot cleaner can quickly remove it before it sets. These machines are designed to tackle specific stains such as wine, coffee, or pet accidents, using specialized cleaning solutions to break down and lift the stain from the fabric.
  • High-Traffic Areas: Areas of your carpet that experience a lot of foot traffic are prone to dirt and grime accumulation. A portable spot cleaner allows you to easily address these areas without needing to deep clean the entire carpet, saving you time and effort while maintaining a fresh appearance.
  • Pet Messes: For pet owners, having a portable spot cleaner is essential for dealing with accidents or muddy paw prints. These cleaners often come with attachments specifically designed for pet hair and odors, making it easier to keep your home smelling fresh and looking clean.
  • Upholstery Cleaning: Portable spot cleaners are also effective for cleaning upholstered furniture. They can remove stains from sofas, chairs, and car interiors, helping to extend the life of your furniture and keep it looking new.
  • Seasonal Deep Cleaning: During seasonal cleaning or after events, a portable spot cleaner can help touch up areas that need extra attention. Instead of renting a large machine for the entire carpet, you can quickly spot clean the trouble areas, making your cleaning routine more efficient.
  • Convenience and Portability: The compact design of portable spot cleaners allows for easy storage and mobility. You can take them to various rooms in your home or even use them in your vehicle, making them a versatile cleaning tool for everyday messes.

What Are the Best Carpet Cleaning Services in Minneapolis?

The best carpet cleaning services in Minneapolis offer a combination of quality, expertise, and customer satisfaction.

  • Steam Pro Carpet Cleaning: Known for its eco-friendly products, Steam Pro Carpet Cleaning provides deep cleaning services that effectively remove stains and allergens. They utilize advanced steam cleaning technology, ensuring carpets are cleaned thoroughly while remaining safe for pets and children.
  • Oxi Fresh Carpet Cleaning: Oxi Fresh is recognized for its innovative, low-water cleaning system that dries quickly and reduces water usage. Their green-certified solutions effectively lift dirt and stains, making it ideal for environmentally conscious customers.
  • Stanley Steemer: A well-established name in the carpet cleaning industry, Stanley Steemer offers comprehensive services including carpet, upholstery, and tile cleaning. Their trained technicians use powerful equipment and techniques that not only clean but also help maintain the longevity of carpets.
  • Clean & Green Carpet Cleaning: This service specializes in organic cleaning methods, using biodegradable products that are safe for the environment. Clean & Green Carpet Cleaning focuses on providing high-quality service while minimizing their ecological footprint.
  • EcoClean Solutions: EcoClean Solutions uses a unique cleaning process that revolves around non-toxic, green products. They are highly rated for their customer service and effectiveness in removing tough stains and odors without harmful chemicals.

How Can DIY Carpet Cleaning Methods Be Effective?

DIY carpet cleaning methods can be effective by utilizing common household items and techniques that offer a cost-effective and environmentally friendly solution.

  • Baking Soda: Baking soda is a powerful natural deodorizer and can effectively absorb odors from carpets. By sprinkling it on the carpet and letting it sit for several hours or overnight, you can neutralize unpleasant smells, and then vacuum it up to reveal fresher carpet.
  • White Vinegar: White vinegar serves as an excellent stain remover and disinfectant. When mixed with water and applied to stains, it breaks down dirt and grime, making it easier to blot out the stains without damaging the carpet fibers.
  • Dish Soap: A simple mixture of dish soap and water can effectively tackle grease and food stains. Applying a few drops of dish soap mixed with warm water to the affected area helps lift the stain, and blotting it with a clean cloth removes the residue.
  • Steam Cleaning: Using a steam cleaner can deeply penetrate carpet fibers, loosening dirt and allergens while sanitizing the surface. This method is particularly effective for high-traffic areas and can be done at home or by renting a unit from a local store.
  • Club Soda: Club soda is effective for removing stains from carpets, especially those caused by beverages. The carbonation helps lift the stain, while the sodium content can act as a cleaning agent, making it easier to blot away the mess.
  • Hydrogen Peroxide: Hydrogen peroxide is a potent stain remover that can be used on light-colored carpets. It helps break down tough stains like blood or wine, but it should be used cautiously as it may bleach darker fabrics.
  • Essential Oils: Essential oils, such as tea tree or lavender oil, can be added to homemade carpet cleaning solutions for added antibacterial properties and pleasant scents. They can enhance the cleaning process while providing a fresh aroma to your living space.

What Tips Can Improve DIY Carpet Cleaning Results?

Here are some effective tips to enhance your DIY carpet cleaning results:

  • Choose the Right Carpet Cleaner: Selecting the best carpet cleaner suitable for your specific carpet type is crucial. In Minneapolis, research local options that cater to your carpet’s fabric, whether it’s wool, synthetic, or a blend, to avoid damage while ensuring effective cleaning.
  • Pre-Treat Stains: Before deep cleaning, it’s essential to pre-treat any visible stains. Use a stain remover specifically designed for carpets, applying it according to the instructions, and allowing it to sit for a few minutes to break down the stain before cleaning the entire area.
  • Use Hot Water: Utilizing hot water during the cleaning process can significantly improve dirt removal. Heat helps to dissolve grease and grime more effectively, making your cleaning solution more potent and enhancing the overall cleaning results.
  • Vacuum Thoroughly Before Cleaning: A thorough vacuuming before deep cleaning is vital to remove loose dirt and debris. This step prevents dirt from being pushed deeper into the carpet fibers during the cleaning process, allowing for a more effective clean.
  • Follow the Manufacturer’s Instructions: Always adhere to the manufacturer’s guidelines for your carpet cleaner. This includes recommended cleaning solutions, settings, and techniques to ensure optimal results and to protect your carpet from potential damage.
  • Don’t Over-Saturate the Carpet: When cleaning, it’s important to avoid over-saturating the carpet with water. Excess moisture can lead to mold and mildew growth, so use the cleaning machine’s extraction feature effectively to remove as much water as possible.
  • Allow Proper Drying Time: After cleaning, ensure the carpet dries completely before walking on it. Open windows, use fans, or turn on the air conditioning to promote airflow, which helps speed up the drying process and prevents odors.
  • Consider Professional Help for Tough Stains: For persistent or difficult stains, it may be beneficial to consult professional carpet cleaners. They often have advanced tools and solutions that can tackle tough stains and restore your carpet to its original condition.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment