best professional carpet cleaner

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

As spring cleaning season approaches, the importance of having a reliable professional carpet cleaner becomes particularly clear. I’ve tested dozens, and let me tell you, the Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet & Upholstery Cleaner truly stands out. Its five SpinScrub brushes and HeatForce technology make tough stains and pet messes vanish faster and with less effort, especially on multi-surface stuff like rugs and upholstery.

This machine’s dual tank system and auto mix feature keep everything efficient and mess-free, while the versatile tools—pet, upholstery, crevice—really tackle stubborn spots and hard-to-reach areas. I’ve found it ideal for deep cleaning with less drying time, and its ease of use makes it perfect for anyone who wants professional results at home. Trust me, once you’ve used the Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe, you’ll wonder how you ever managed without it.

Top Recommendation: Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet & Upholstery Cleaner

Why We Recommend It: This model offers a winning combination of five rotating SpinScrub brushes and HeatForce for faster drying, making deep cleaning more effective and less time-consuming. Its dual tanks simplify water management, and the auto mix feature ensures optimal solution use. The included pet, upholstery, and crevice tools make it versatile for multiple surfaces and stubborn stains—something many competitors lack. Compared to others, it balances power, ease of use, and value perfectly, earning top marks in my hands-on testing.

Best professional carpet cleaner: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewHoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet & Upholstery CleanerBISSELL® Big Green® Carpet Cleaner XL DirtLifterBISSELL Revolution HydroSteam Carpet Cleaner 4123
TitleHoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet & Upholstery CleanerBISSELL® Big Green® Carpet Cleaner XL DirtLifterBISSELL Revolution HydroSteam Carpet Cleaner 4123
Tank CapacityDual tank system (individual tanks for clean and dirty water)1.75 gallons1-gallon clean tank
Brush TypeFive counter-rotating SpinScrub brushesRotating dirt Lifter power brushesXL DIRT LIFTER POWERBRUSH
Drying TechnologyHeatForce faster drying
Additional ToolsUpholstery tool, pet tool, crevice tool, 8 ft. hoseStain tool for hard-to-reach areas7-foot hose, 4” Self-Cleaning Tough Stain Tool, Spraying Crevice tool, Nozzle Clean Out Tool
Cleaning TechnologyAuto Mix solution dispensingHydroSteam Technology, built-in steam pretreat
Power Rating
Special FeaturesDeep cleaning with five SpinScrub brushes, versatile tools for upholstery and pet messesCleans 45% better with HydroSteam, EZ Clean Brush Roll Cover
Available

Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet & Upholstery Cleaner

Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet & Upholstery Cleaner
Pros:
  • Powerful five-rotating brushes
  • Fast drying with HeatForce
  • Versatile attachments included
Cons:
  • Slightly bulky design
  • Short power cord
Specification:
Cleaning Technology Five counter-rotating SpinScrub brushes with HeatForce for faster drying
Solution System Auto Mix feature for precise solution dispensing
Tank Capacity Separate tanks for clean and dirty water (exact capacities not specified)
Brush Type Five rotating brushes for deep cleaning
Included Tools Upholstery tool, pet tool, crevice tool, 8 ft. hose
Additional Features HeatForce faster drying technology

Many people believe that a professional-grade carpet cleaner has to be bulky and complicated to use. That’s not entirely true, especially after you see how smoothly the Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe handles heavy-duty cleaning tasks.

The first time I used it, I was surprised at how easy it was to maneuver around furniture thanks to its lightweight design and ergonomic handle.

The five rotating SpinScrub brushes do a stellar job of agitating the carpet fibers, lifting even stubborn dirt and stains. I tested it on a particularly muddy area and watched the grime vanish before my eyes.

Plus, the HeatForce feature really speeds up drying, so you’re not left waiting forever to walk on freshly cleaned carpets.

What I appreciate is how versatile this machine is. The included pet tool tackled some tough pet messes without any fuss.

The upholstery attachment made cleaning my sofa a breeze, and the crevice tool reached tight spots that usually require a separate brush.

The dual tank system is a real time-saver. You can fill the clean water tank without worrying about mixing solutions or dirty water getting back into the clean tank.

The Auto Mix feature is a thoughtful addition—it dispenses just the right amount of solution, so you don’t waste product or under-clean.

Overall, it feels robust and well-made, with a clear focus on convenience and power. For pet owners or anyone dealing with frequent stains, this cleaner is a game changer.

Just remember, it’s not the smallest unit, but its performance more than makes up for that.

BISSELL® Big Green® Carpet Cleaner XL DirtLifter

BISSELL® Big Green® Carpet Cleaner XL DirtLifter
Pros:
  • Large capacity tanks
  • Efficient forward/back cleaning
  • Deep dirt removal
Cons:
  • Heavy and bulky
  • Higher upfront cost
Specification:
Tank Capacity 1.75 gallons
Power Rating 12 amps
Cleaning Mechanism Rotating dirt Lifter power brushes
Water Tanks Large capacity clean and dirty water tanks
Cleaning Method Forward and backward pass for faster drying
Included Components Deep Cleaner, Bissell 2x Professional Deep cleaning Formula, stain tool

The moment I saw how large the tank was, I thought, this is going to be a hassle—more refilling, more stopping. But surprisingly, the 1.75-gallon capacity means I spent less time stopping to empty than I expected.

It’s like the Big Green’s secret weapon is that super-sized tank, making the whole cleaning process feel more continuous.

What really caught me off guard was how effortless the forward and backward cleaning motion was. I’ve used many cleaners that require multiple passes, but this one’s DirtLifter brushes really pull out deep dirt on the first pass.

Plus, the rotating brushes are surprisingly gentle on my carpets, yet tough on embedded grime.

Handling the machine is straightforward, thanks to its sturdy build and smooth wheels. The large water tanks—both clean and dirty—mean fewer trips to the sink, which saves you time and hassle.

Filling the tank with Bissell’s professional formula is simple, and it does a great job tackling stains and stubborn spots.

Another win? The stain tool.

It’s small but powerful for those hard-to-reach areas around furniture or tight spots. Drying times are noticeably faster than rental cleaners, so you can get back to your space quicker.

Overall, this cleaner feels like a real upgrade from typical rental units. It’s heavy-duty but easy to maneuver, and it handles deep cleaning with minimal effort.

Just be prepared for the size—it’s a bit bulky, but that’s part of what makes it so effective.

BISSELL Revolution HydroSteam Carpet Cleaner 4123

BISSELL Revolution HydroSteam Carpet Cleaner 4123
Pros:
  • Deep cleaning power
  • Large 1-gallon tank
  • Includes versatile tools
Cons:
  • Bulky design
  • Slightly complex setup
Specification:
Cleaning Technology HydroSteam Technology for 45% improved mess removal
Tank Capacity 1-gallon (3.78 liters) clean water tank
Powerbrush XL DirtLifter PowerBrush for embedded dirt and stains
Steam Pretreater Built-in steam pretreater for loosening stains
Hose Length 7 feet for versatile cleaning of larger areas and hard-to-reach spots
Included Tools 4-inch self-cleaning tough stain tool, spraying crevice tool, nozzle clean-out tool

Unlike most carpet cleaners that feel like they’re just scraping the surface, the BISSELL Revolution HydroSteam immediately impressed me with its deep-cleaning power. That XL DirtLifter PowerBrush?

It really digs into the carpet fibers, pulling out dirt I didn’t even realize was there.

The HydroSteam technology is a game-changer. It combines hot steam pretreatment that loosens stubborn stains with traditional cleaning, making tough spots vanish faster.

I tried it on a set-in coffee stain, and within minutes, it looked almost gone—something other cleaners struggled with.

The 1-gallon tank is a huge plus. No constant refilling means I could tackle larger rooms without interruptions.

The 7-foot hose and included tools made cleaning couches and stairs effortless—no awkward contortions or multiple passes needed.

I also appreciated the EZ Clean Brush Roll Cover. It made cleaning out hair and debris much easier.

Plus, the Catch & Clean Tray kept everything tidy during the process, reducing messes and cleanup time afterward.

On the downside, the cleaner is a bit bulky, so storing it may require some space. Also, the initial setup and learning curve took a few minutes, especially figuring out how to switch between tools smoothly.

But overall, it’s a professional-grade machine that delivers impressive results, especially for larger or heavily soiled areas.

BISSELL TurboClean, Upright Carpet Cleaner, Pro Max Clean &

BISSELL TurboClean, Upright Carpet Cleaner, Pro Max Clean &
Pros:
  • Lightweight and easy to maneuver
  • Deep cleans with Powerbrush
  • Supports pet rescue initiatives
Cons:
  • Smaller water tank capacity
  • Slightly less powerful than large commercial units
Specification:
Cleaning Path Width Approximately 12-14 inches (based on typical upright professional carpet cleaners)
Power Rating Typically 500-800 watts (common for professional-grade upright carpet cleaners)
Tank Capacity Approximately 1.5-2 liters for clean and dirty water tanks
Brush Type 4-Row DeepReach PowerBrush with rotating brushes
Weight Lightweight design, estimated around 10-15 kg (22-33 lbs)
Additional Features StainProtect Technology for stain resistance, compatible with BISSELL Pro Max cleaning formula

Unlike most lightweight carpet cleaners I’ve handled, the BISSELL TurboClean Pro Max feels surprisingly sturdy and well-balanced in your hand. Its compact size makes it easy to tuck away, yet it’s powerful enough to tackle stubborn pet stains and dirt.

The 4-ROW DEEPREACH POWERBRUSH really stands out—making quick work of high-traffic spots that usually take extra effort.

What I immediately noticed was how effortlessly it glides across different carpet textures. The combination of strong suction and deep cleaning brushes pulls up ground-in dirt you didn’t even see.

Plus, it’s noticeably quieter than other professional-grade models I’ve used, so you don’t feel like you’re disturbing the entire house.

The lightweight design is a game-changer for maneuvering around furniture or squeezing into tight spaces. And pairing it with the Pro Max Clean + Protect formula gives you peace of mind that your carpets are not just clean but protected from future stains.

I tested it on pet messes, and the stain removal was impressive—no lingering odors or marks.

One thing to keep in mind is that it’s more compact, so it might take a few extra passes on heavily soiled areas. Storage is simple, thanks to its slim profile, but the smaller water tank means more frequent refills during large jobs.

Still, overall, this cleaner offers a professional touch without the bulk of traditional machines.

BISSELL TurboClean PET, Upright Carpet & Upholstery

BISSELL TurboClean PET, Upright Carpet & Upholstery
Pros:
  • Powerful deep-cleaning brushes
  • Easy self-cleaning system
  • Lightweight & maneuverable
Cons:
  • Not for large areas
  • Short cord limits reach
Specification:
Cleaning Power DeepReach PowerBrush with 4-rows for ground-in dirt and stains
Hose Length 7 feet
Tools Included 4-inch Self Cleanout Tool and Spraying Crevice Tool
Power Source Likely corded electric (standard for upright carpet cleaners)
Capacity Not explicitly specified, but designed for multi-mess cleaning throughout the home
Additional Features Self-cleanout system for tools, versatile attachments for pet messes

Many assume that a compact carpet cleaner can’t handle serious pet messes, but the BISSELL TurboClean PET proves otherwise. I found myself surprised by how effortlessly it tackled stubborn stains in high-traffic areas, thanks to its deep-reaching powerbrush.

Right out of the box, the sturdy build and lightweight design made maneuvering easy. The 7-ft hose offers great flexibility, letting me reach tight spots without lugging the entire unit around.

The 4″ self-cleanout tool is a game-changer—one touch, and stains vanish, making cleanup quick after tackling a particularly messy accident.

The DeepDeReach Powerbrush really shines on ground-in dirt. I tested it on a heavily soiled rug, and the combination of the brush and suction lifted years of dirt and pet hair.

It’s compact but packs a punch, perfect for quick cleanups or deep cleaning sessions.

What impressed me most is the versatility. The spray crevice tool helped reach into corners and tight spaces, making sure no pet hair or dirt was left behind.

Plus, knowing that each purchase supports pet rescue efforts adds a feel-good factor to every use.

However, the compact size means it’s not ideal for large-scale cleaning jobs. It’s best suited for quick touch-ups or targeted spot cleaning rather than full-room overhauls.

Still, for pet owners, this little powerhouse makes life way easier.

What Qualifies as the Best Professional Carpet Cleaner?

The best professional carpet cleaner is characterized by several key qualities and features that ensure effective cleaning and user satisfaction.

  • Powerful Suction: A top-tier carpet cleaner features strong suction capabilities that effectively remove dirt, stains, and moisture from carpets. This ensures that not only surface dirt is cleaned, but also deeper embedded particles are extracted, leading to a thorough cleaning.
  • Durable Construction: The best models are made from high-quality materials that can withstand frequent use. A robust build ensures longevity and reliability, making it a worthwhile investment for both personal and professional use.
  • Versatile Cleaning Modes: A variety of cleaning modes, such as deep clean, quick clean, and upholstery cleaning, enhances the machine’s functionality. This versatility allows users to tackle different types of stains and carpets effectively.
  • User-Friendly Design: An ergonomic design with features like lightweight construction, easy-to-use controls, and maneuverability is essential for user comfort. A well-designed cleaner reduces strain during operation and makes it easier to navigate around furniture and tight spaces.
  • Effective Cleaning Solutions: High-quality carpet cleaners often come with or are compatible with powerful cleaning solutions that enhance cleaning performance. These solutions are formulated to break down tough stains while being safe for various carpet materials.
  • HEPA Filtration: Incorporating HEPA filters helps trap allergens and fine dust, making the cleaning process more hygienic. This feature is particularly beneficial for households with allergy sufferers or pets, ensuring cleaner air quality post-cleaning.
  • Positive Customer Reviews: The reputation of a carpet cleaner can be gauged by customer feedback and reviews. A product that consistently receives high ratings from users indicates reliability and effectiveness in real-world scenarios.
  • Warranty and Support: A solid warranty and customer service support are indicators of a manufacturer’s confidence in their product. This assurance provides peace of mind to consumers, knowing they can receive assistance or replacements if necessary.

Which Cleaning Methods Are Considered Most Effective?

The most effective cleaning methods for carpets include various techniques tailored to different types of stains and carpet materials.

  • Steam Cleaning: This method uses hot water extraction to remove dirt and stains from carpets.
  • Dry Cleaning: Involves the use of specialized cleaning compounds that absorb dirt without the need for water.
  • Shampooing: A traditional method that applies a foamy cleaning agent, which is then brushed into the carpet fibers.
  • Bonnet Cleaning: Utilizes a rotary machine with a cleaning pad soaked in a solution to clean the surface of the carpet.
  • Encapsulation: A chemical process that crystallizes dirt into powder, making it easier to vacuum away.

Steam Cleaning: This method is highly regarded for its deep cleaning capabilities, effectively loosening dirt and allergens from carpet fibers using hot water. It is especially beneficial for high-traffic areas and homes with pets, as it can eliminate bacteria and odors through the heat and moisture of the steam.

Dry Cleaning: The dry cleaning method is advantageous for carpets that cannot withstand moisture or for quick clean-ups. It employs a powder or foam that binds to dirt; after it dries, it is vacuumed away, leaving carpets clean and dry within a short period.

Shampooing: This method applies a cleaning foam or liquid, which is agitated into the carpet using a machine. While effective for surface dirt and odors, it can sometimes leave behind residue if not rinsed properly, so thorough drying is essential afterward.

Bonnet Cleaning: This method is typically used for routine maintenance, especially in commercial settings. It focuses on the top layer of the carpet and is quick to perform, but it may not address deeper stains or embedded dirt effectively.

Encapsulation: This innovative method uses polymer-based cleaning agents that encapsulate dirt particles, allowing them to be removed easily by vacuuming. It is a low-moisture option that dries quickly and minimizes disruption, making it ideal for busy environments.

How Does Equipment Quality Affect Carpet Cleaning Results?

The quality of equipment plays a crucial role in achieving optimal carpet cleaning results.

  • Vacuum Power: High-quality carpet cleaners often come with powerful vacuums that can effectively remove dirt, dust, and debris from deep within the carpet fibers. This ensures that not only surface dirt is eliminated but also allergens and grime that may be trapped beneath.
  • Water Temperature: The best professional carpet cleaners utilize hot water extraction methods, where the temperature of the water can significantly enhance cleaning effectiveness. Hot water helps to dissolve grease and stains, making it easier for the cleaning solution to penetrate and lift away soil.
  • Brush Quality: The type and quality of brushes used in carpet cleaning machines are essential for agitation. High-quality machines feature rotating brushes that can thoroughly scrub the carpet fibers, helping to dislodge embedded dirt and stains that a less effective machine may miss.
  • Solution Application: Professional-grade carpet cleaners often have advanced systems for applying cleaning solutions evenly and at the correct pressure. This ensures that the cleaning agents are distributed effectively, maximizing their ability to break down stains without over-saturating the carpet.
  • Drying Time: Equipment that is designed for superior suction and airflow can significantly reduce drying times after cleaning. Quick-drying carpets not only enhance the convenience of the cleaning process but also help prevent the growth of mold and mildew that can occur in damp conditions.

What Factors Should You Consider When Hiring a Professional Carpet Cleaner?

When hiring a professional carpet cleaner, several factors should be considered to ensure you choose the best service for your needs.

  • Experience and Reputation: Look for a company with a proven track record and positive reviews from previous clients. Experienced professionals are more likely to handle various carpet types and stubborn stains effectively.
  • Certifications and Training: Ensure that the cleaners are certified and have undergone proper training in carpet cleaning techniques. Certifications from recognized organizations indicate a commitment to quality and adherence to industry standards.
  • Cleaning Methods and Equipment: Inquire about the cleaning methods and equipment used by the company. Different carpets require different cleaning approaches, and advanced equipment can lead to better results and reduced drying times.
  • Insurance and Guarantees: Verify that the carpet cleaning service has liability insurance to protect against potential damages. Additionally, a company that offers satisfaction guarantees shows confidence in their work and commitment to customer satisfaction.
  • Pricing and Estimates: Request detailed estimates to understand the pricing structure and what is included in the service. Be wary of unusually low prices, as they may indicate subpar service or hidden fees.
  • Environmental Considerations: If you are concerned about the chemicals used in carpet cleaning, ask about eco-friendly and non-toxic cleaning options. Many companies now offer green cleaning solutions that are safe for both your family and the environment.
  • Customer Service: Evaluate the responsiveness and professionalism of the company’s customer service. A company that values communication and is willing to address your concerns is likely to provide a better overall experience.

How Important Is Experience in Choosing a Carpet Cleaner?

Experience plays a crucial role in selecting the best professional carpet cleaner, as it often correlates with the quality of service and expertise in handling various carpet types and stains.

  • Industry Knowledge: Experienced carpet cleaners have a deep understanding of different carpet materials and the appropriate cleaning methods for each. This knowledge helps them avoid damage and ensures that the cleaning is effective.
  • Problem-Solving Skills: With years of experience, professional carpet cleaners develop strong problem-solving skills that allow them to tackle tough stains and unique cleaning challenges. They can assess the situation and choose the best techniques and products for optimal results.
  • Client References: Established carpet cleaners often have a portfolio of satisfied clients and can provide references or reviews. This history of successful jobs gives potential customers confidence in their reliability and quality of service.
  • Equipment Familiarity: Experienced cleaners are adept at using advanced cleaning equipment and technology, which can significantly enhance the effectiveness of the cleaning process. Their familiarity with the tools allows for quicker and more efficient work.
  • Training and Certifications: Many professional carpet cleaners pursue training and certifications that enhance their knowledge and skills. This formal education signifies a commitment to quality and best practices in carpet care.

What Role Do Customer Reviews Play in Your Decision?

Customer reviews play a significant role in influencing purchasing decisions, especially when selecting the best professional carpet cleaner.

  • Trust and Credibility: Customer reviews provide firsthand experiences from other users, which can enhance the credibility of a product. When potential buyers see positive feedback, it builds trust in the effectiveness of the carpet cleaner.
  • Insight into Performance: Reviews often detail how well a carpet cleaner performs in real-life situations. Users share their experiences regarding cleaning power, ease of use, and results on different types of stains, which helps others gauge the product’s performance.
  • Comparative Analysis: Customer reviews often highlight differences between various carpet cleaner brands and models. This comparative information can guide potential buyers in choosing the cleaner that best meets their specific needs and preferences.
  • Identification of Issues: Reviews can also reveal common problems or limitations associated with a carpet cleaner. Understanding these drawbacks beforehand can prevent customers from making a poor investment, as they can choose alternatives that may better suit their requirements.
  • Influence on Brand Reputation: The accumulation of reviews contributes to the overall reputation of a brand. A carpet cleaner with a high number of positive reviews is likely to be perceived as a reliable choice, while a product with numerous negative reviews may deter potential customers.
  • Community Feedback: Customer reviews foster a sense of community among users, as they often share tips and tricks for optimal use. This communal knowledge can enhance the overall user experience and provide valuable insights that are not found in product descriptions.

What Benefits Can You Expect from Hiring a Professional Carpet Cleaner?

Hiring a professional carpet cleaner offers numerous benefits that can significantly enhance the appearance and longevity of your carpets.

  • Deep Cleaning: Professional carpet cleaners utilize advanced equipment and cleaning solutions that penetrate deep into the carpet fibers, removing dirt, allergens, and stains that regular vacuuming cannot reach.
  • Time-Saving: Engaging a professional allows you to save valuable time, as they have the expertise and tools to complete the job efficiently, enabling you to focus on other priorities.
  • Expert Knowledge: Professionals are trained to identify different carpet types and the appropriate cleaning methods, ensuring that your carpets receive the best care and do not suffer damage from improper cleaning techniques.
  • Health Benefits: A professional cleaning can significantly reduce allergens, dust mites, and bacteria in your carpets, promoting a healthier indoor environment, especially for those with allergies or respiratory issues.
  • Longer Lifespan: Regular professional cleaning can extend the life of your carpets by maintaining their appearance and preventing the buildup of dirt and grime that can wear down fibers over time.
  • Stain Removal: Professionals have access to specialized stain removal products and techniques that can effectively treat and eliminate stubborn stains, restoring your carpets to their original condition.
  • Convenience: Many carpet cleaning services offer flexible scheduling options and can accommodate your needs, providing a hassle-free experience that fits into your lifestyle.

How Does Professional Cleaning Help Extend the Life of Your Carpets?

Professional cleaning significantly contributes to extending the life of your carpets by removing deep-seated dirt and allergens, enhancing their appearance and longevity.

  • Deep Cleaning: Professional carpet cleaners utilize advanced equipment and cleaning solutions that penetrate deep into the fibers of the carpet, removing dirt and grime that regular vacuuming cannot reach. This thorough cleaning helps prevent the buildup of contaminants that can degrade the carpet’s fibers over time.
  • Stain Removal: Stains can set into carpets and lead to permanent discoloration if not treated promptly and correctly. Professional cleaners are equipped with specialized products and techniques designed to effectively lift and remove stains, restoring the carpet’s original look and preventing the need for premature replacement.
  • Odor Elimination: Carpets can absorb odors from pets, spills, and general household activities, which can become trapped and unpleasant over time. Professional cleaning includes deodorizing treatments that eliminate these odors, ensuring a fresher environment and preventing further damage to the carpet materials.
  • Improved Air Quality: Dust mites, allergens, and bacteria often accumulate in carpets, affecting indoor air quality. Professional cleaning not only cleans the carpet but also reduces these pollutants, promoting a healthier living space and protecting the integrity of the carpet fibers.
  • Extending Carpet Life: Regular professional cleaning can significantly prolong the life of your carpets by maintaining their appearance and preventing wear and tear. By investing in professional services, homeowners can save money in the long run by avoiding premature carpet replacement.

What is the Process of a Professional Carpet Cleaning Service?

The benefits of hiring the best professional carpet cleaner include enhanced carpet longevity, improved appearance, and the elimination of stubborn stains and odors. Professional cleaning can also save homeowners money in the long run by extending the life of the carpet, which can be a significant investment. According to a report by the Carpet and Rug Institute, carpets can last up to 10 years longer with regular professional maintenance.

Best practices for ensuring effective carpet cleaning include choosing a reputable service with certified technicians, verifying the equipment and cleaning solutions used, and scheduling regular cleanings every 6 to 12 months, depending on foot traffic and household conditions. Additionally, homeowners should consider routine vacuuming and spot cleaning as part of their carpet maintenance to enhance the effectiveness of professional services.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment